Wednesday, 27 July 2022

Supreme Court Judgement on minimum judicial interference by the NCLAT and NCLT in the framework of IBC

Minimum Judicial Interference by the NCLAT and NCLT in the Framework of IBC: SC

 A Bench comprising of Justices B.R. Gavai and Hima Kohli of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India vide Judgment dated 3rd June, 2022 in the matter of Vallal RCK Vs. M/s Siva Industries and Holdings Limited and Ors. (Civil Appeal Nos. 1811-1812 of 2022) held that National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) and the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) should not sit in appeal over the commercial wisdom of the Committee of Creditors (CoC).

Facts:

IDBI Bank Limited had filed a Section 7 application under the IBC for the initiation of the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (‘CIRP’) against Siva Industries (Corporate Debtor). The said Application was admitted by NCLT and CIRP in respect of the Corporate Debtor was initiated. Subsequently, the Resolution Professional presented a Resolution Plan before the CoC and the said Plan received only 60.90% votes of the CoC and did not meet the requirement of receiving 66% votes. Hence, the said Plan could not be approved.

Further, Resolution Professional filed an application under Section 33(1)(a) of the IBC seeking initiation of liquidation process of the Corporate Debtor. Subsequently, Vallal RCK (Promoter of the Corporate Debtor), filed a settlement application under Section 60(5) of the IBC before the NCLT, offering one­time settlement plan. Meetings of the CoC were held to consider the Settlement Plan as submitted by the appellant. There were wide deliberations among the members of the CoC with regard to the said Settlement Plan and suitable amendments were carried out and the final Settlement Plan was approved by 94.23% votes.  

Accordingly, the Resolution Professional filed an application before the learned NCLT seeking withdrawal of CIRP initiated against the Corporate Debtor. However, NCLT, held that the said Settlement Plan was not a settlement simpliciter under Section 12A of the IBC but a “Business Restructuring Plan” and rejected the application for withdrawal of CIRP and approval of the Settlement Plan. Moreover, the learned NCLT initiated liquidation process of the Corporate Debtor. Aggrieved by this, the appellant preferred two appeals before the learned NCLAT. Vide the common impugned judgment dated 28th January 2022, the same was dismissed against which the appeals were filed before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.

Held:

Firstly, the Court while deciding upon the said appeal referred to Section 12-A of the IBC which deals with withdrawal of application admitted under Section 7, 9 or 10 on an application made by the applicant with the approval of ninety percent voting shares of Committee of Creditors. It was further noted that Section 12-A was added to the Code vide Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Second Amendment) Act, 2018 (Act No. 26 of 2018) which was brought in on the basis of Insolvency Law Committee (“Committee”) Report. Clause (vii) of the Committee reads as under –

"(vii) in order to cater to exceptional circumstances warranting withdrawal of an application for CIRP post­ admission, it has been recommended to allow such exit provided the CoC approves such action by ninety per cent of voting share;"

The Court also referred to Para 29 of the Committee Report which states that the intent of the IBC is to discourage individual actions for enforcement and settlement and the Committee recommended that the relevant rules may be amended to provide for withdrawal post admission if the CoC approves of such action by a voting share of ninety percent.

In light of the above, the Court observed that approval of Resolution Plan requires 66% of CoC approval and withdrawal of CIRP requires 90% of CoC approval which could clearly reflect that more stringent provision was made as withdrawal of CIRP is concerned.

Moreover, the Court also referred to Regulation 30A which was added to the Regulations, 2016 which lays down the detailed procedure for withdrawal of application.

Thereafter, the Court also referred to the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Swiss Ribbon Private Ltd Vs Union Of India (2019) 4 SCC 17 vide which the validity of section 12A of the Code was upheld. Moreover, many other judgments passed by Supreme Court was considered where it was already held that commercial wisdom of CoC is of paramount status and that the financial creditors are fully informed about the viability of the corporate debtor and feasibility of the proposed resolution plan.

Therefore, it was held that

“24. When 90% and more of the creditors, in their wisdom after due deliberations, find that it will be in the interest of all the stake-holders to permit settlement and withdraw CIRP, in our view, the adjudicating authority or the appellate authority cannot sit in an appeal over the commercial wisdom of CoC. The interference would be warranted only when the adjudicating authority or the appellate authority finds the decision of the CoC to be wholly capricious, arbitrary, irrational and de hors the provisions of the statute or the Rules.”

The appeals were allowed and the Application filed by Resolution Professional before the NCLT for withdrawal of CIRP was also allowed.

Case Name: Vallal Rck v. M/s. Siva Industries And Holdings Limited And Ors.

Case No.: Civil Appeal Nos. 1811-1812 of 2022

Judgment Date: 03 June 2022

Bench: Justices B.R. Gavai and Hima Kohli

This Article has been Compiled by Ayushi Misra (Senior Associate) and Arun Gupta (Partner). 

  You can direct your queries or comments to the author at info@factumlegal.com

  Disclaimer-

  The contents of this article should not be construed as legal opinion. This article is             intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be     sought about your specific circumstances. We expressly disclaim any financial or other   responsibility arising due to any action taken by any person on the basis of this article.

Thursday, 21 July 2022

Dissolution without Liquidation

 Dissolution without Liquidation – Is it even possible?

In India, there are a lot of companies with liabilities and no assets and idea of closure of the company is to be contemplated as there does not exist future prospects in the company. One of the options for those companies is to undergo Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process and then liquidation process if resolution plan is not approved by the Committee of Creditors or no viable resolution plan is received. For those companies with no assets, liquidation process can seem like a cumbersome and time taking process when the companies have no assets to liquidate. In this article, we explore the possibility and viability of any option which paves the way for early dissolution of such companies without undergoing the normal liquidation process as envisaged under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 ('IBC’).

Every distressed company has to go through a hierarchy of processes which include a compulsory insolvency resolution process prior to liquidation and the final dissolution only after the competition of such liquidation process. Thus, every company dissolved pursuant to the IBC has to mandatorily undergo the preceding Corporate Insolvency Regulation Process (“CIRP”) and liquidation process.

Now the question for consideration is whether a company has to compulsorily undergo a liquidation process under IBC?

In order to answer the question, we can refer to the following provisions:

Section 54 of IBC- Application for Dissolution- where the assets of the Corporate Debtor have been completely liquidated, the liquidator shall make an application to the Adjudicating Authority for the dissolution of such Corporate Debtor.

Regulation 14 of the IBBI (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016- Early Dissolution- if it appears to the Liquidator that:

  1. the realizable properties of the Corporate Debtor are insufficient to cover the cost of the liquidation process; and
  2. the affairs of the corporate debtor do not require any further investigation;

He may apply to the Adjudicating Authority for early dissolution.

Rule 11- NCLT Rules, 2016- Inherent Powers of NCLT- Nothing in these rules shall be deemed to limit or otherwise affect the inherent powers of the Tribunal to make such orders as may be necessary for meeting the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the tribunal.

Analysis

A conjoint reading of the aforementioned provisions suggests that an application of dissolution shall be made where the assets of the corporate debtor are completely sold. Hence, it may be naturally implied that where the Corporate Debtor has no assets at the very commencement of the liquidation, the liquidation period may not be required.

The following question has been answered in a number of judgements passed by the National Company Law Tribunal (“NCLT”):

In Synew Steel Pvt Ltd CP (IB)N.96/BB/2020, initially the application was filed under Section 10 of the IBC read with Rule 7 of I & B (AAA) Rules, 2016, inter alia seeking to initiate CIRP in respect of the M/S Synew Steel Pvt Ltd on the ground that it has committed default of an amount of Rs. 1, 18,56,964/- which includes claims from both Financial Creditors and Operational Creditors. The Adjudicating Authority admitted the case and CIRP was initiated in respect of the Corporate Applicant.

It was pointed out by the Insolvency Resolution Professional (IRP) that he is unable to constitute the Committee of Creditors (COC) because there were no assets (movable or immovable) with the Corporate Debtor except a cash balance of Rs. 729/-. The entire share capital of the Corporate Debtor was eroded. Because of no business being conducted by the Corporate Debtor in the last 3 years, there has been no revenue.

The NCLT referred to the following provisions before going into the merits of the case

  1. Section 54 of IBC
  2. Rule 14 of IBBI (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016
  3. Rule 11 of NCLT Rules, 2016

The Tribunal held that “there would be no useful purpose served, by placing the Corporate Debtor under a Liquidation Process, under the extant or provisions of Code. Since the Assets of Company were realized, the liquidation process under the provisions or Code is deemed to have been completed under Chapter III of Part II of Code and thus it would be just and proper for the Adjudicating Authority to dissolve the company as proposed by the Resolution professional and the Applicant Company i.e. Synew Steel Private Limited is ordered to be dissolved with immediate effect”.

After considering the aforementioned cases and provisions, it is safe to say that early dissolution of a company is a viable option for a Corporate Debtor seeking to dissolve the company in a timeframe shorter than that in normal liquidation process. However, the process for ‘dissolution without liquidation’ (early dissolution) is not as straight forward as it seems and requires careful consideration on various issues before approaching the Hon’ble NCLT as the NCLT has complete discretion to reject the application for early dissolution if it is not satisfied with the reasons and has done so on previous occasions. 

This Article has been Compiled by Aditya Raj (Associate) and Arun Gupta (Partner). 

  You can direct your queries or comments to the author at info@factumlegal.com

  Disclaimer-

  The contents of this article should not be construed as legal opinion. This article is             intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be     sought about your specific circumstances. We expressly disclaim any financial or other   responsibility arising due to any action taken by any person on the basis of this article.

 

Tuesday, 19 July 2022

Power and Scope of NCLT to recall its order

 

POWER AND SCOPE OF NCLT TO RECALL ITS ORDER

The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) in Printland Digital (India) Pvt. Ltd. Versus Nirmal Trading Company (Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 504 of 2022) vide Order dated 30.05.20222 ruled on the issue whether the Adjudicating Authority has the power to recall its order.

Background of the case:

The right to file the Reply of Printland Digital (India) Pvt. Ltd. (the Appellant) as Corporate Debtor was closed vide Order dated 22.07.2021 against which the Appellant had filed an application on 16.09.2021 for recalling of the Order. The Application for recalling the order dated 22.07.2021 was dismissed by the Order dated 10.03.2022 passed by the Adjudicating Authority (National Company Law Tribunal, New Delhi, Court-IV) in I.A. No. 5064/ND/2021 in CP No. IB1105/ND/2020 on the grounds that Tribunal is not vested with the power to recall or review its own order but also sufficient opportunities were granted to the Appellant to file the Reply which were not availed. Hence, the Appellant filed an Application for recalling the order dated 22.07.2021.

Contentions of the Appellant

1.   The Tribunal has the jurisdiction to recall its order under Rule 11 of the NCLT Rules, 2016 as the Tribunal had not decided upon any substantial issue on merits. The Rule 11 of the NCLT Rules is reproduced herein:

“11. Inherent Powers.- Nothing in these rules shall be deemed to limit or otherwise affect the inherent powers of the Tribunal to make such orders as may be necessary for meeting the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the Tribunal.”

2.   The Appellant relied upon the Order dated 16.03.2022 in CA (AT) (Ins) 271 of 2022 wherein the Tribunal was faced with similar facts wherein right to file Reply was closed but on application filed therein the reply was taken on record.

Contentions of Nirmal Trading Company (the Respondent)

1.   The Appellant was granted several opportunities by Adjudicating Authority to file a reply which were deliberately not availed. Thus, the act and conduct of Appellant does not require interference by the Court.

Held

NCLT relied upon the Order dated 16.03.2022 in CA (AT) (Ins) 271 of 2022 and Rule 11 of the NCLT Rules and allowed the Appeal and remanded the case back to the Adjudicating Authority to consider the application on merits and decide the same in accordance with law. It was held that the Adjudicating Authority has no jurisdiction to review its order after deciding a substantial issue, but the Adjudicating Authority has the jurisdiction to recall the order of the kind in dispute i.e. where the right to Reply was closed by an order on the ground that the opportunities granted were not availed.

This Article has been Compiled by Ayushi Misra (Senior Associate) and Arun Gupta (Partner). 

  You can direct your queries or comments to the author at info@factumlegal.com

  Disclaimer-

  The contents of this article should not be construed as legal opinion. This article is             intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be     sought about your specific circumstances. We expressly disclaim any financial or other   responsibility arising due to any action taken by any person on the basis of this article.